Tony Polecastro smiling with a sunburst acoustic guitar

Acoustic Tuesday  ·  Tony's Acoustic Challenge  ·  Presented by The Acoustic Shoppe

Tony Polecastro's Gear List

Tony's Acoustic Tuesday show is a big part of why we started making videos of our own, so it meant a lot when he ranked our channel fifth on his 2021 list of the best guitar shop channels on YouTube. Everything on Tony's list ships from our shop in Springfield, Missouri.

600K+Subscribers on his YouTube channel
16,000+Active students in Tony's Acoustic Challenge
600+Guitars he had reviewed by 2020
2014The year he launched the Acoustic Challenge

01How Tony got here

From a music store in Chicago to Acoustic Tuesday

Tony picked up the guitar at 18, and the Dobro was the first instrument he got serious about. From about 2005 to 2008 he worked in the music store at the Old Town School of Folk Music in Chicago, first buying lesson books and then buying instruments, and the teachers there are the ones who pointed him toward Tony Rice, Earl Scruggs and Kelly Joe Phelps.

In 2008 he moved to Montana and sold for Weber Mandolins, then went to work at Music Villa in Bozeman. That's where he and Levi, now his business partner, started The Acoustic Letter, playing the same songs on different guitars back to back and putting out a new video every Tuesday. Tony started Acoustic Tuesday because he wanted to invite people into what he thinks can be an intimidating world.

02The gear

What's on Tony's list

Every item on Tony's list links to its page on our site, where you can see whether it's in stock today.

03The guitarsenal

Four of Tony's own guitars

Tony calls his collection the guitarsenal, and he talked about each of these four on a 2020 episode of Acoustic Tuesday.

I've never met an object that holds as much emotional weight as a guitar. Tony, TAS Knows People, 2025
  • His first real guitar

    Martin HD-35

    Tony bought the HD-35 as his first “real” guitar, and it had been with him since his first gig.

  • Sold to his dad

    Martin D-41 Special

    Tony's dad owned this D-41 Special after buying it from Tony, who was working at the Old Town School of Folk Music at the time.

  • From Della Mae

    Bourgeois Country Boy

    Courtney Hartman played this Country Boy when she was in Della Mae, and Tony calls it a bluegrass cannon that cuts through when you flatpick fill after fill.

  • The fingerpicker

    Santa Cruz Vintage Southerner

    Tony said he tends to favor the shorter-scale Vintage Southerner for fingerpicking.

Those four are Tony's, but we carry all three brands.

Martin guitars → Bourgeois guitars → Santa Cruz guitars →

05The shop

Why buy it from us

We're a 12-time NAMM Top 100 Dealer, and every instrument on Tony's list goes through our 23-Point Professional Inspection before we box it up.

Any instrument $1,000 and up carries our Dread-Not Guarantee, which gives you a full year to trade it in for up to 90% of the pre-tax purchase price in credit, less round-trip shipping, plus a 30-day in-home trial.

If you have a question about anything on the list, call the shop and we'll help.

Shop Tony's Gear List →

Questions

Does Tony earn anything when I buy from this page?

He does. Every store link here carries Tony's Community Pro referral tag, so he earns a commission and you pay the same price you would anywhere on our site.

Can I buy the guitars from Tony's guitarsenal?

No, those four are Tony's own, but we stock Martin, Bourgeois and Santa Cruz, and the links under his guitarsenal go to each brand in our shop.

Where can I learn guitar with Tony?

Start at tonypolecastro.com, where he runs Tony's Acoustic Challenge, which teaches adults one familiar song a week through five skills.

Affiliate disclosure: Tony Polecastro is a TAS Community Pro and earns a commission when you buy through the links on this page. It costs you nothing extra.